Blackstone Pizza Oven vs Ooni - A Side By Side Comparison with Chart

Ooni vs Blackstone Pizza Oven Introduction

If you’re a home pizzaiolo, unless you’ve been living under a rock, or rather a pizza stone, you’ve probably heard of Ooni and Blackstone. These two amazing brands are everywhere, and for good reason—they both make some seriously good products. But with so many models to choose from, it can be tough to decide which one is right for you. In this guide, we’ll take a deep dive into both brands and compare their features, cooking performance, and value to help you figure out which one will suit your style, whether you're a seasoned pro or just looking to make a great pie.

Blackstone vs Ooni: Blackstone Overview

Blackstone has been a big player in high-quality flat-top grills, which has earned them their fame. But did you know, this reputation for delivering exceptional cooking equipment extends into pizza ovens? Blackstone offers grill add-on pizza ovens as well as standalone pizza ovens with the sturdy build and powerful cooking performance you’d expect from Blackstone. These ovens come with a generous cooking area and a large burner (standalone models), making them a great choice for large gatherings or cooking multiple pizzas simultaneously. Whether you’re looking to cook a classic Margherita or something more exotic, a Blackstone pizza oven may be just what you need to get the job done. 

Blackstone Pizza Oven Models:

1. Blackstone Leggero ($264.99):

Key Features:

• 13-inch Rotating Cordierite Stone: Ensures even cooking without the need for manual rotation.
• Built-In Temperature Gauge: Allows for precise temperature monitoring, ensuring your pizzas are cooked to perfection every time.
• Easy Temperature Control Knob: Provides straightforward adjustments to achieve your desired cooking temperature.
• Functional Utility Door with Stable Locking Positions: Helps retain heat effectively, enhancing cooking efficiency.
• Portable Design: Lightweight and compact, making it easy to transport and set up for any outdoor occasion.

2. Blackstone Pizza Oven with Cart ($699.00):

Moving up a notch, we have Blackstone’s Pizza Oven with Cart. This pizza oven is powerful and lightweight, designed for outdoor enthusiasts who want to cook pizza with ease. As the name implies, this oven includes a cart to make moving and storage simple.This is the perfect model for the beginner pizzaiolo with its rotating pizza stone to take the guesswork out of rotating pizzas.

Key Features:

• Rotating Cordierite Pizza Stone: Ensures even cooking without manual rotation.
• High Temperature Capability: Reaches over 900°F, cooking pizzas in as little as 90 seconds.
• Electric Push-Button Ignition: Provides a convenient and reliable ignition system.
• Mobile Cart with Swivel Casters: Allows for easy movement and storage.

3. Blackstone Select Pizza Oven ($1499.00):

Next up is the Blackstone Select. The Select is a standalone pizza oven designed for serious outdoor cooking. With a large cooking surface and powerful burner, it delivers consistent heat for cooking multiple pizzas at once. Perfect for those who want to make pizzas for family and friends, the Select is built to last with a sturdy construction and a sleek design.

Key Features:

• Rotating 16-inch Cordierite Pizza Stone: Provides even cooking for perfectly baked pizzas every time.
• 304 Stainless Steel Construction: Built to withstand outdoor conditions and deliver long-lasting durability.
• Electric Auto "Safe Start" Ignition: Ensures safe and reliable ignition with automatic gas shutoff if ignition fails.
• Propane Storage Cabinet: Keeps your propane tank neatly stored and easily accessible.
• Dual Side Shelves with Tool Hooks: Offers extra prep space and convenient storage for your pizza-making tools.
• Locking Swivel Casters: Makes it easy to move and lock the oven in place for stability.

4. Blackstone Portable Pizza Oven ($399.99):

The final standalone model in the Blackstone lineup is the Portable Pizza Oven. This oven is a propane-powered tabletop oven. Its compact size makes it ideal for tailgating, camping, or small backyard gatherings while remaining large enough to fit a 15in cooking surface. This means it is a bit bulkier than your typical portable pizza oven but well worth it. With its patented 2-Stone Technology and efficient cooking chamber, it ensures your pizzas cook evenly and quickly.

Key Features:

• Patented 2-Stone Technology: Utilizes both a bottom and top cordierite stone to provide consistent heat distribution
• High Heat Retention: The cooking chamber is designed to perfectly lock in heat, allowing for fast cooking times and a crispy crust
• Portable Design: Its compact and lightweight build makes it easy to transport and set up, perfect for on-the-go cooking.
• Included Accessories: Comes with a pizza peel and a rocking pizza cutter, enhancing your pizza-making experience.

5. Blackstone OTG Pizza Oven Conversion Kit

If you already own a Blackstone griddle or want one appliance to do it all, Blackstone makes pizza oven conversion kits. Available for both 17-inch and 22-inch griddles, this kit allows you to turn your griddle into a pizza oven! Although these conversion kits are made specifically for the 17” tabletop griddle and 22” flattop griddle only.

Key Features:

• Patented 2-Stone Technology: Includes both an upper and lower cordierite stone to provide even heat distribution for perfectly cooked pizzas.
• Heat-Retaining Front Door: Helps maintain optimal temperature within the oven, ensuring your pizzas cook faster and more efficiently.
• Built-In Thermometer: Allows precise temperature monitoring to achieve perfect pizza results every time.
• Easy Conversion: Quickly and easily transforms your Blackstone griddle into a pizza oven with minimal setup required.

Ooni vs Blackstone: Ooni Overview

Ooni is perhaps the biggest name in pizza ovens. They are a brand that lives and breathes pizza. From day one, they’ve focused entirely on crafting high-heat pizza ovens to bring pizzeria-quality cooking to backyards and patios. Their lineup includes everything from ultra-portable gas ovens to hybrid-fuel models that let you cook with wood, charcoal, or propane gas. Ooni ovens are capable of reaching very high temperatures, some up ever exceeding 900°F, an essential component to cooking Neapolitan-style pizzas. Compact, efficient, and purpose-built, Ooni is a go-to for home pizzaiolos to achieve professional results from a simple setup.

Ooni Pizza Oven Models:

1. Ooni Fyra 12 ($349.00):

The Ooni Fyra 12 delivers wood-fired authentic, Neapolitan-style pizzas in a lightweight portable package. Fueled by hardwood pellets, it can quickly reach temperatures of up to 950°F (500°C) . Weighing only 22 lbs (10 kg), it's perfect for outdoor adventures, tailgating, or small backyard gatherings.

Key Features:

• Wood Pellet Fuel: Hardwood pellets offer quick and  consistent heat with a traditional wood-fired taste.
• Rapid Heating: Reaches 950°F (500°C) in just 15 minutes.
• Portable: Lightweight and compact for easy transport.

2.  Ooni Karu Series

If you are someone looking for a little more flexibility in your cooking, the Ooni Karu might be the choice for you. It offers multi-fuel capabilities, allowing you to cook with wood, charcoal, or gas. Available in 4 varieties, the  Karu 12,  Karu 16, or the new Karu 2 and Karu 2 Pro, this oven delivers professional-quality results to any outdoor space.

Ooni Karu 12 ($299.00):

Key Features:

• Multi fuel: Wood, charcoal, or gas capabilities (burner sold separately).
• Portable: Compact and weighs only 26.5lbs (12kg).
• Rapid high-heat: Heats to 950 °F/500 °C in 15 minutes and cooks pizzas in just 60 seconds.

Ooni Karu 16 ($799.00):

Key Features:

• Large cooking surface: Cook pizzas up to 16” in diameter.
• Multi-Fuel: Wood, charcoal, and optional gas burner (sold separately).
• Rapid high-heating: Reaches up to 932°F in 15 minutes.
• Hinged glass door: View pizza cooking without losing heat.

Ooni Karu 2 ($399.00):

Key Features:

• Borosilicate glass door: View pizza cooking while retaining heat.
• Multi Fuel: Designed to use wood and charcoal or convert to gas with a burner (sold separately).
• High temp: Reaches up to 932°F and cooks in 60 seconds.
• Compact: Lightweight and portable design.

Ooni Karu 2 Pro ($799.00):

Key Features:

• Digital Temperature Hub: Check oven temperatures with the built in display or straight to your phone via Bluetooth.
• Smart cooking: Integrates with Ooni Connect™ smartphone app.
• Large cooking surface: Cooks up to 16in pizzas.
• Multi fuel: Cooks with charcoal, wood, or gas burner (sold separately).
• ClearView™ glass door: Monitor pizza cooking while retaining heat.

3. Ooni Koda Series

The Koda is a popular choice in the Ooni lineup. This series is all gas-powered offering simplicity and low maintenance. The Ooni Koda heats up quickly, reaching temperatures up to 950°F, and can cook Neapolitan-style pizzas in just 60 seconds. Like the Karu, the Koda is available in a wide range to fit your specific needs.

Ooni Koda 12 ($399.00):

Key Features:

• Gas-fired: Uses propane gas for convenience.
• High temp Range: Rapidly heats to temperatures of up to 950°F.
• Portable: Lightweight and compact.
• User-Friendly: No assembly required.

Ooni Koda 16 ($599.00):

Key Features:

• Flexible Fuel Options: Can be fueled with a propane tank or a natural gas line.
• L-shaped flame: convenient one-turn pizza cooking.
• High heat: Reaches up to 950°F.
• Larger Cooking Surface: Accommodates pizzas up to 16 inches.

Ooni Koda 2 Max ($1199.00):

Key Features:

• Extra large 24” cooking surface: Accommodates single pizzas up to 20”, two up to 12” or three 10” pizzas simultaneously.
• Propane fuel: convenient and low maintenance.
• High Temperature Range: Reaches up to 850°F.
• Dual-Burner System: Features two pizza stones and a dual-burner gas system, allowing for cooking multiple pizzas simultaneously or different styles at varying temperatures.
• Smart Features: Includes a built-in thermometer and connectivity with the Ooni app.

4. Ooni Volt 12 ($899.00):

The Ooni Volt 12 is truly one of a kind. Designed for both indoor and outdoor use, this all electric pizza oven reaches temperatures up to 850°F in just 20 minutes, allowing you to cook Neapolitan-style pizzas in just 90 seconds. With adjustable dials for top and bottom heating elements, a built-in timer, and a “Boost mode” for quick reheating, the Volt 12 offers a unique  convenience for home pizza enthusiasts. Its compact design fits comfortably on standard kitchen countertops, making it suitable for various cooking spaces.

Key Features:

• All-Electric Operation: Provides a clean and straightforward cooking indoors or outdoors.
• Adjustable Heating: Control top and bottom heating elements independently for precise cooking.
• Built-In Timer and Temperature Control: Set cooking times and temperatures to suit different pizza styles.
• Boost Mode: Quickly restores cooking temperature between pizzas, ensuring consistent results.
• Compact Design: Fits on standard kitchen countertops, ideal for home kitchens.

Blackstone vs Ooni Pizza Oven Comparison Chart

Conclusion: Blackstone Pizza Oven or Ooni – Which Is Right for You?

Both Blackstone and Ooni have built a reputation for themselves as major players in outdoor cooking. The choice ultimately comes down to your unique preferences, styles, and budget. If you prefer a versatile oven that can handle wood, charcoal, and gas, the Ooni Karu series is a top choice. But if you already know and love Blackstone, and would prefer a convenient add-on for your existing griddle, the conversion kit might be the choice for you. 

We hope this comparison has helped you gain some insight into these two amazing brands to help find the perfect pizza oven for your cooking space. Whether you're making pizzas for a large crowd, or a pizza party of one, Ooni and Blackstone have the equipment to get the job done. 

If you would like to explore some of the other amazing brands in the world of pizza, check out our blog post on the Best Pizza Oven Brands!